ExarchBlade – Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander

ExarchBlade – Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander

Keep innovating.

 

Before I begin the article, I guess I should introduce myself a bit. My name is Adam Alexander and I am from Northern Ireland (though currently residing in Dublin) I am graduating from my finance degree in about 3 weeks and entering the real world… bills and insurance? I have to actually pay for stuff??

DISNEYLAND ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderI have had some modicum of success in my Magic career. Qualifying for Pro Tour Valencia with a home-brew UB Korlash deck in Time Spiral block constructed: I proceeded to 2-3 drop the main event (playing TEPS), no real shock there as it was my first major tournament. From there I had been trying to get back on Tour for about 2 years when I decided to quit Magic (like that ever works) just after Lorwyn block. No sooner had I sold my cards then I was asked by DJ Carson to accompany him to GP Paris. My reaction – DISNEYLAND!!!! Why not? Placed 72nd out of 2000+ players. After this success, I decided I definitely was quitting Magic…

Until Nationals 2010… I had no intention of attending but I was qualified on rating and was bullied into going. So I hopped on a bus the night before, arrived at a collector/ friend’s house and threw together an Esper control deck (without Planeswalkers) and made it to top 4 only playing 4 rounds of constructed.

My two main successes in constructed Magic were a direct result of homebrews, so why should this one be any different.

stoneforge mystic ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderI decided about a month ago that I would attend the PTQ since it was in my back yard and I like free holidays. I had not played competitive Magic since Nationals 2010, but from friends, knew that Caw-blade was the deck to play. Looking over the deck list, the caws themselves seemed weak to me. Whilst generating card advantage, the little dorks were 1/1 flyers which couldn’t block the scary new Sword. It was also vastly apparent that, in the mirror, whoever cast the first Stoneforge Mystic generally won.

I do not like the idea of blaming variance for losses in the mirror. I like a deck to be able to pull a game from the jaws of defeat. Another whisper on the wind was a Splinter Twin-Exarch combo deck. I liked the combo itself, but it seemed weak against hate and had no real reach.

I decided that Exarches were just better than Squadron Hawks in the mirror, as they guarantee you the first Sword/Batterskull hit even if you are on the draw. If Exarchs are in the deck, the addition of Splinter Twin gives the deck reach in the long game, and can break stalemates. It also gives you a win condition against Soul Sisters. So without further ado, the list:

ExarchBlade by Adam Alexander

stoneforge mystic ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander3x preordain

3x spell pierce

2x divine offering

4x stoneforge mystic

3x into the roil

2x tumble magnet

1x sword of war and peace

1x sword of feast and famineDeceiver Exarch ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander

2 x Jace Beleren

4x deceiver exarch

2x day of judgement

3x splinter twin

3x Jace the Mind Sculptor

1x Gideon Jura

1x BatterskullConsecrated Sphinx ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander

1x consecrated sphinx

 

3x scalding Tarn

2x Arid Mesa

4x Seachrome Coast

2x celestial Colonnade

Tectonic Edge ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander

4x island

3x plains

3x mountain

2x tectonic edge

1x mystifying maze

 

SB.

Gideon Jura ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander1x Gideon Jura

1x sun titan

2x dismember

2x divine offering

3x leyline of sanctity

3x flashfreeze

1x day of judgement

2x celestial purge

*****

Unfortunately I did not take notes of the matches but I will do a brief recap from memory.

Side note 1: A total of 15 minutes testing was done with this deck prior to the tournament to ensure the mana base worked like the math said it would.

Side note 2: There were 38 players at the PTQ

 

Round 1: Gavin Mcleese – Mono red

Koth of the Hammer ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderI started this tournament in grand fashion: Game Loss for deck miss-registration and my opponent is playing mono red… great.

–Wait… Game loss for him as well!

I keep a hand with some Exarches and an Into the Roil. He starts with a Spikeshot Elder and a Koth. My life total drops to 12 vs. his 17, I Preordain into the combo and win.

1:0


stoneforge mystic ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander

Round 2: Mike… Local Shop Owner – Hawkward.

G1. All he sees is the combo and I kill him on turn 6.

G2. He has side boarded for the combo, I turn2 Stoneforge Mystic and go to town.

2:0

 

Round 3: Brandon Downs – Dark blade.

I get blown out both games by keeping shaky openers and his discard. Most notable in G2 I cast and get to use 3 Jace variants and still get no more than 6 lands L cough *variance* cough.

2:1

 

Round 4: Jake… I think. Sorry dude. Caw blade.

Splinter Twin ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderG1. He wins the roll, and goes first (obv). Be beats me round the head with equipment and I die.

G2. I do that to him (after casting my Splinter Twin with a Spellskite in play, but let’s not mention that!).

G3. 2 minutes on the clock… No matter how fast I play, I cannot hope to combo off in time… ID.

2:1:1

 

Inferno Titan ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderRound 5: Fergus Looney – RUG

G1. He gets an Inferno Titan and my life drops to 6, then I combo’ed and win.

G2. He was never really in… He only drew a handful of spells cough *variance* cough.

3:1:1

 

Round 6 (Win and in): Conor Holmes – Dark blade.

Consecrated Sphinx ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderG1. Goes long… really long. My Tumble Magnets and Mystifying Maze keep his equipped dorks and Emeria Angel at bay long enough to let me stick a Consecrated Sphinx.

G2. 15 min on clock. I get stuck on 4 land for ever and scoop with 6 minutes left.

Myself and Conor are good friends, and we are both on the bubble. If this game goes to time, it could get awkward. So we play, post-haste.

G3. I combo turn 5/6 and that’s all she wrote.

4:1:1

 

Top 8!

Splinter Twin ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderQuarters: Brandon Downs – Dark blade.

G1. Brandon gets an active Jace first, but I am able to bounce it and stick my own, along with a Consecrated Sphinx, riding the 8-12 cards to victory.

G2. I can’t really remember, I Splinter Twinned a Stoneforge at one point for my final Sword.

 

Semis: Mark McGovern – Soul Sisters.

Batterskull ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderG1. I’m short on land and he Tec’ Edges my Colonnade and batter(skull)s me to death.

G2. I combo off.

G3. I cast my combo and almost go for it, before realising that Mark has 2 sisters in play which would insta-kill me. I bounce both next turn and kill.

 

 

Finals: Dave Murphy – B/R Vampires.

Manic Vandal ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderG1. Variance in my favour – 3 land 2 Stoneforge, Jace. My first Stoneforge gets Batterskull and her throat torn out. The second one gets Sword of Feast and Famine. My Batterskull meets a main deck Manic Vandal and dies. The Sword sticks and I win.

G2. Yayy variance loves me – basically the same hand as above. Dave has a more aggressive hand and gets a lot of guys out. I have a Sworded Exarch on board vs. his Lacerator, Vandal, Highborn and Bloodghast, (with Dark Tutelage on board). I DoJ with Gideon and Consecrated Sphinx in hand and 5 lands, with him on 10 life, planning on riding Gideon to victory. He gets Duressed (obv) and I miss land for a turn or 2 while he gets guys again. I draw Exarch to stem the tide and Preordain into a Twin for the victory and the blue envelope.

*****

Mental Misstep 1 ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam AlexanderI really enjoyed playing this deck. It seemed to have a good match up against the Caw-blade variants, and was able to pull a victory from the jaws of defeat. I would not change the main board but the sideboard needs updating. The white Leyline is bad. Full stop. And I didn’t use Dismembers at all. My current thoughts are 4 Mental Misstep/1 Celestial Purge or 3 Mental Misstep/2 Spellskite.

The deck has two very different modes of play while only really requiring 3 cards to facilitate the inclusion of the combo variant.

I do not by any means think that I have made a format defining deck; rather, this article aims to show that innovation in a stagnant format can sometimes pay off.


Thanks for reading and keep innovating,

Adam

 ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander ExarchBlade   Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander
ExarchBlade – Belfast PTQ 1st Place Report by Adam Alexander
0 votes, 0.00 avg. rating (0% score)

Please let us know what you think below...

  1. ‘barring any variance’ ahahahahahahaha

    Darkblade decks play 27 lands of which 0/1 are colourless. UW cawblade play 26/27 lands of which 4-6 are colourless. To play a deck with worse mana than Darkblade (need RR UU and WW) and play the same number of coloured lands as straight UW, and fewer overall lands, is simply not going to work over a big sample vs opponents who are able to register their decks correctly, read their cards, play them in something close to the right order (but might be ok for 38 player irish ptqs if you get a bit lucky).

    Unfortunately ‘variance’ as you call it tends to happen in games of magic

  2. Adam Alexander June 2, 2011, 12:53 pm

    I figured I had better defend the deck slightly as it did get me an invite.

    First of all, my bad; I made a mistake in the deck list: 25 land . missing a glacial fortress, not a basic. gives mana sources @ 14u, 13w,8r,3 colourless. There are also 12 draw spells, 4 mystic, 5 jace variants, 3 preordain.

    Using basic probability theory, if we assume we are on play, and no mulligan, by turn 5 we should have drawn 2.15 draw spells. Including this. barring any variance there should be 5.32 lands of which 2.5 are blue, 2.128 are white and 1.01 are red (one of which will be a fetchland)

    (I am allowing that all draw spells net you one card even though half let you see up to 3 cards to account for the fact that stoneforge does not draw a random card.)

    The deck isn’t trying to assemble the combo quickly, rather, it is using the combo as an alternate meant to victory through stalemated board positions, un winnable scenarios like “Soul Sisters” infinite life combo. This means that achieving RR in the early turns in not required in most circumstances.

    The main aim of the deck is to play a tempo based aggro strategy, much like caw, but use the tap down abilities of the exarchs, magnets, to some degree gideon, as well as use into the roil to aggressively to gain the advantage.

    I am just trying to give reasoning beind my decisions for my manabase. Granted, it could be wrong, but I am just trying to explain how I arrived my decisions

  3. was the round 1 gameloss for misregistering a result of judges just looking at the manabase and assuming something was wrong?

  4. Tomoharu Saito June 1, 2011, 3:20 pm

    I’m not sure you can blame variance on getting mana screwed when you’re playing 24 lands and 3 preordain in a 3 colour deck that needs UU, RR and W and will usually want 5+ lands

  5. Congratulations on the win, enjoy the pro tour :D. Do you have any changes you’d make to the deck? It looks like you might be a bit light on consistent red mana.

  6. James Griffin May 31, 2011, 2:25 pm

    This deck looks like a real mash up of strategies – isn’t splinter twin a really awkward card in your hand most the time? That said maybe it works like NO Bant in Legacy, and plays aggro, with an occasional ‘oops I win’. Nevertheless, sacrificing card advantage to play a combo which likes you to draw as many cards as possible still seems awkward. What do you think?

  7. hey,

    sorry about the crappy reports, I wasn’t expecting to be writing an article. I was soo much happier to have pierce main, and the 4th preordain became a 3rd into the roil. The extra tempo spell seemed good most of the day. I can’t really remember a time I was looking for a preordain.

    And Brandon is probably right . . . but better lucky than good :).

  8. You beat me game 2 by me letting you kill my batterskull.

    Now that I’ve seen your actual decklist, I’m confused. Only 3 preordains? Pierce over any manaleaks? You really are the luckiest magic player in Ireland :P

  9. It’s a shame you can’t remember what happened in the matches, as the deck looks really interesting to play (despite being CawBlade :P), and has that all-important unexpected Plan B. Congrats, sir!

Leave a Reply