So, here we are three weeks after the start of the Deck Building Competition and Rob, Cyrus and myself have chosen the decks that we each think are our personal favourites. We’re going to summarise each one and we will use the previous article for the early starters who are in the running rather than have people trawl back to the last article.
GR Furnace Celebration – Dan Barrett.
Cyrus – “This deck should happily beat a lot of aggro decks and take on Caw blade due to the removal levels in it.”
“A lot going on here, with multiple sac outlets, and lots of things happening when you do sacrifice creatures. The deck is built around Eldrazi Spawn (ideally from an Awakening Zone) + Furnace Celebration = lots of Shocks, but some other things to note:
Sylvok Lifestaff + Eldrazi Spawn = 3 life for each spawn you have, for effectively zero mana, which should easily put you out of range vs aggro decks.
Red Sun’s Zenith is good for a few points of damage early on, and gives you something big to do with your inevitable excess of mana when drawn again later.
Mortarpod gives a blocker for a turn plus a point of damage, and gives you a sacrifice outlet for non-spawn creatures.
Fetches not only improve your mana, but are good for 2 damage when topdecked, in conjunction with Furnace Celebration.
Raging Ravine is another card that both improves manabase and is fine to draw later on – overall I think the deck is pretty resilient.
Sideboard options include:
Sylvok Replica as artifact/enchantment removal that sacrifices in the process, or blocks until you need him. At a later point you may want to mix this with Manic Vandal/Naturalize so you have a quicker answer to Swords.
Spawning Breath is a bit too narrow for the main, but a couple could be boarded in against certain decks.
Culling Dais is probably at least worth trying versus decks that can clear the board regularly.” – Dan Barrett
Pop Idol by Freedrinkdave.
4 Myr Sire
2 Iron Myr
Cyrus – “First glance, I didn’t like the list much, but as I started counting up it’s removal and synergies, I began to like it more, and I’ve seen first hand how savage Jinxed Idol can be, Mortopod and Masticore in the deck are rather sweet too. The manabase feels a little light, but I think it has all the right ingredients, and is an interesting list.”
This deck revolves around Jinxed Idol and recurring Kuldotha Phoenix once you have metalcraft from all the equipment. Molten-tail Masticore has the dual purpose of getting your Phoenixes into the bin and turning those dead Myr into burn.” – Freedrinkdave
Budget Forgemaster by Marty Cauchi.
2x Trinket Mage
3x Doom Blade
4x See Beyond
Cyrus – “Obviously lacking the really expensive Planeswalkers but I think trading power for defensive capabilities looks good in this deck and should be a good deck to take to FNM.”
“Wins are generally like this:
Various artifacts such as Everflowing Chalice, Tumble Magnet and Elixir of Immortality are on the battlefield alongside Kuldotha Forgemaster. Trinket Mage helps to get them there. At the end of your opponents turn after you play Forgemaster, sacrifice 3 other artifacts and play a Myr Battlesphere. End of next turn you sacrifice 3 Myrs with the Forgemaster and play Mindslaver. Cause havoc. Back to your turn and you finish them off with damage from the Battlesphere and the Forgemaster.
See Beyond is useful for putting any of the expensive artifacts back and getting replacements, Removal to slow down your opponent, I couldn’t fit in Inquisition, so Duress is disruption. Platinum Emperion can stop most decks from killing you until they deal with it.
This deck is fun to play because of all the answers you can search up with Trinket Mage and Forgemaster.
Emeria Titans by Ben Downton.
4x Sun Titan
2x Ratchet Bomb
2x Mimic Vat
“The premise with this is fairly straightforward – survive until turn 5/6. Making unfavourable trades and even hitting Day of Judgement into your own men to buy a turn or two mean you have time to set up the Titan/Emeria combo. Having a Sun Titan and Emeria out at the same time requires an opponent to be able to deal with ‘both’ simultaneously or one can simply recur the other.
There is reusable card draw in the Wall of Omens, reusable lifegain in the Missionary, and Expedition Maps can be used to search for more Emerias, recurring Tectonic Edges to shutdown lands, or most things in the deck with an ETB trigger. Top tip: Use Emeria to bring back a Sun Titan and then trigger the Sun Titan to bring back something else 😉
I played this a lot pre-scars and had reasonable success with it. Post Scars the only thing that concerns me matchup wise is maybe Valakut (Leyline for game 2) and Infect decks. With Infect not ‘quite’ breaking in yet I plan to bust this out at FNMs again.
Proelferate – Laura Dawes.
16 x Forest
4 x Llanowar Elves
4 x Arbor Elf
4 x Joraga Warcaller
4 x Copperhorn Scout
4 x Contagion Clasp
4 x Tumble Magnet
1 x Contagion Engine
Cyrus – “Pretty basic idea, but looks a lot like normal elves and comes in on budget, with a few neat tricks. Seems more competitive than most of the other entries.”
Rob – “Looks like a very competitive deck actually. Coupled with a punned name and an underpants gnome reference this looks like a winner.”
Mark – “You just gotta love the cheesy name pun and then you see a lovely deck.”
“The deck’s main plan is….
1. Put +1/+1 counters on elves
This aggressive deck has several plans to help it recover from the enemy’s board sweepers with Ezuri, Renegade Leader providing regeneration for your other elves, and Lead the Stampede as a way to refill your hand.
The deck is 47% creatures, so you should expect to draw 2 – 3 creatures when you cast Lead the Stampede.
There are several fun interactions available in this deck. Ezuri, Copperhorn Scout and mana elves all play well together – when you attack with your creatures, the Copperhorn Scout untaps all of your elves, and with mana elves you can activate Ezuri’s overrun ability.
Oran-Rief, the Vastwood gives out +1/+1 counters which can then be proliferated with Contagion Clasp or Congagion Engine. Joraga Warcaller especially enjoys having some +1/+1 counters added to him, boosting all the rest of your little green men.
The 2 Viridian Corrupters are an elf-based removal spell for pesky artifacts such as equipments that grant protection from green. And who knows, perhaps once in a while you will get poison counters onto your opponent and proliferate for the win!
The sideboard recommendations would include:
Naturalize and/or more Viridian Corrupters – board these in when facing the Swords as they both grant protection from green, and against decks with lots of artifacts such as the Grand Architect blue deck.
Leyline of Vitality – this is essential when playing against mono red burn decks to help you survive later into the game. This can help along with +1/+1 counters to make your elves tough enough to survive Lightning Bolts. The leyline is also a great card when the opponent has burn-based sweepers like Pyroclasm.
Leatherback Baloth – this man is not an elf, but he is huge and easily castable in this deck, so also very good against decks with lots of burn spells.” – Laura Dawes
Look Sac by Michael Radford.
2x Mimic Vat
4x Ember Hauler
4x Doom Blade
“There are a couple of different ways to win with this deck, but my favourite (also the most unlikely) is to have a huge Mortician Beetle and then flinging it in response to removal. Repeatable pinging from an Ember Hauler under Mimic Vat is slow but offers inevitability. Alternatively, the myriad removal available to this deck means that you might just get your opponent’s best creature under the Mimic Vat. Consuming Vapors can give you reach against control decks with big creatures while gaining you minimal life against aggro and getting you something under your Vat. However, it should probably be sided out against aggro for something like Slagstorm or Black Sun’s Zenith.
My current sideboard plan would probably look something like this. Corpsehatch may look janky but it’s good fuel for the Demon plan. It can also create chump blockers against an all-in aggro deck like K-Red. Jinxed Idol has shown its use against creature-light control decks, while Manic Vandle obviously has a ton of applications in the current meta game. Arc Trail is another useful addition but don’t really fit the A Game in the maindeck and I couldn’t really find a place for them in the board. If Corpsehatch is too crappy it can easily be replaced by Trail. I wasn’t sure about the budget for the sideboard, so Viscera Seer is me erring on the side of cost saving. Obviously there are far superior options for a deck like this, although it obviously has sweet synergy with Bloodghasts (again, omitted due to budget constraints).
2x Jinxed Idol
4x Viscera Seer
3x Manic Vandal” – Michael Radford
“Love Life and Live” by Daniel Matthews.
2 x Ajani Goldmane
2 x Kor Skyfisher
3 x Serra Ascendant
4 x Kemba’s Skyguard
4 x Soul’s Attendant
2 x Narrow Escape
4 x Survival Cache
2 x Dread Statuary
2 x Sejiri Steppe
16 x Plains
Mark – “Okay, I like life gain, what can I say.”
All the cards besides Ajani Goldmane cost 3 mana or less so it should play fairly quickly, but effectiveness on lifegain has been maximised while keeping these play costs low.
Serra Ascendant” – Daniel Matthews
We also have a few decks from the first time round which have stood the test of time and are in contention for First Prize.
Wall-E by Andy Edwards.
Rob – “A great deck name and synergy. Probably not competitive enough but I would have a lot of fun playing it.”
Cyrus – “A great design, a lot of potential, a little light win con wise, but it looks to be getting there.”
Mark – “There was a Wall deck at the Nottingham NQ and it made the qualification slots, lots of creatures with Defender and then whoosh tap a Battlement for a Genesis Wave for lots and then out can Admonition Angel and friends. I still like this build though but the recent Hero of Oxid Ridge tech may make it more fragile.”
Mark – “I hadn’t really noticed this deck before I started doing my review of the Forum and when both Rob and Cyrus emailed me I was intrigued. Okay, I don’t think I will be running it next week in Sheffield at the National’s Qualifier but I could see myself working on this to be an FNM deck. This deck is so cool with all the Wall synergies.”
UB Poison – Grant Hislop.
Cyrus – “A pretty solid deck, Ichorclaw Myr is the only thing I’d suggest changing in the list, and possibly mana leak swapped with spell pierce, but it looks like it could win quite effectively since crusader alone wins games, and the rest of the deck is pretty well sculpted.”
Mark – “I love this deck, I built up a black blue aggro deck for Mirrodin Besieged Gameday using a very similar engine going 3-0. I disagree with Cyrus on the Ichorclaw Myr, I think they are great as if someone blocks them they become bigger being able to take out most things and a wall of omens in two shots.”
And one final mention…
Infectious Piss by Jim Bowie.
This is what Jim had to say about his deck:
“Gonna keep this short and sweet, it’s a straight black infect deck that wins by dropping inq/Duress on T1, an infect dude on T2, and a Piston Sledge on T3. Sledge puts on an amazing amount of pressure, and also lets you take advantage of your Necropedes to pay the equip cost and kill/weaken a blocker, possibly finishing it off thanks to Contagion Clasp. The deck runs Flensermite over Plague Stinger just because of the dominant role that Squadron Hawks are playing right now. The life gain can actually be more relevant than the semi-but-not-really evasion that Plague Stinger should have had.
Changes to the deck for me would be the addition of Inkmoth Nexus, and I’d use two copies of Hand of the Praetors over the two Vampire’s Bites. Sideboard options include Doom Blade, Marsh Casualties, the Plague Stingers, Disfigure, Vampire Hexmage, and Memoricide.” – Jim Bowie
And as Judge’s we liked the deck, should have made our short lists and maybe even have won the whole thing. Such a shame then that this deck missed the deadline by an hour but really good effort Jim.
Okay Top Three’s from us all:
1) Gr Furnace Celebration
2) UB Poison
2) Budget Forgemaster
3) Emeria Titans
1) UB Poison
3) Love Life and Live
and our winners are…
wait for it…
Most Fun – Look-Sac by Micahel Radford.
Looks pretty fun, flinging a massive guy at their head. And there weren’t too many really janky cards in here.
Most Innovative – Wall-E By Andy Edwards.
Commented on this before, nice tribal synergy and something no-one else looked at (I’ve seen 100 Myr decks -_-).
3rd Place – GR Furnace Celebration by Dan Barrett.
We had a lot of choices for third place as many decks in contention but as Cyrus had decided this was his number one choice it deserved a place in the top three like the choice of Rob and myself.
2nd Place – UB Poison by Grant Hislop.
Had my top place vote and Cyrus had in second place so a worthy runner up from one of the countries more outrageous deck builders.
1st Place – The mtgUK 2011 Design a Deck Competition Winner – Proelferate by Laura Dawes!
All three of the Judges had you in our Top Three’s and we also believe that this deck could be a nightmare to face at FNM.
Thank you for everyone who took part as this has been a blast looking at the decks, the advice and the community spirit from the competition. May we ask at this point that all winners please contact Manaleak (info@Manaleak.com) as soon as possible with your full name, postal address and from the email address that you had used to register your mtgUK account. This is so we can confirm your identity and ship your prizes to you.
And remember to keep visiting mtgUK guys and girls, we look forward to hearing your comments and suggestions on the next mtgUK competition.